Here is a little mini-review of the RDX that I posted in another thread (I am primarily comparing it to the q5 3.0t):
We got a killer deal on a 2013 AWD w/ tech ($22.5k) with only 12k miles, and the cheapest way for us into a q5 that we wanted was almost $37k (salvage/repairable). The rdx is super quiet and comfy on the highway, and believe it or not I got 30mpg on the way home from where we picked it up (70 mph avg, 75 miles). I still like the q5 3.0t alot more, but I came to the realizations that (A.) it is my wife's car (not mine), (B.) that she liked the rdx alot (especially for the price), and (C.) that this way we can have a reliable car in the garage that is somewhat fuel efficient and luxurious. I will probably end up with some kind of German sports sedan as my next car, and I am happy to have a car in the garage that I hopefully won't have to fix :thumbup:
If I had to sum up the RDX, it is just an easy car to drive and live with. It's really smooth and quiet, great in the snow, fuel-efficient, quick, and luxurious on the inside. But it lacks the enthusiast "spark" that the q5 3.0t has. It doesn't stand out to me, but I value performance and handling over luxury and quiet/ smoothness. My wife is the opposite, and this RDX certainly leans toward refined luxury over sportiness. Now don't get me wrong, with 276 naturally aspirated horses under the hood, the thing hauls (more than the q5 2.0t). It is faster than my stock gti to 60. The engine sounds great too. It just feels more like a luxo-crossover than a performance one - again, missing that enthusiast "spark".
Also, while the tow rating of only 1500lbs is pitiful, there seems to be a lot more useable space in the rdx than the q5, both in the hatch area and the rear seats. I could comfortably sit behind myself in the rdx- not so in the q5. The seats are very comfortable in the RDX as well, and the leather is buttery smooth.
It's kind of hard to describe, but I guess you could say the RDX is just a really nice and easy car to own. It's the jack of all trades (like the gti), but it appeals to the luxury owner who wants value, not an enthusiast looking for a moddable sporty car experience (like the gti does). It certainly is a great value, but if it was my primary car I would save for the q5 3.0t. Since its not, I am super pumped that my wife loves it, because it's a great car for her ( and me too). And at the price we paid, it was the clear choice for us. Honestly, we were hoping to be into our next car for under $30k after we sold the 'tek, and with the q5 that wasn't a realistic option. With the RDX, we will be well under $20k into it; it was a no-brainer for us.