I was told only a VW parts depot can cut keys, and only dealer equipment can do the programming. You know of a locksmith that has the equipment? And even $240 is a good price. Dealers in my area wanted $300 when the MK7's first came out. Also, unless the service people know you personally, you need to bring the car in and prove who you are and that you own the car, and they want payment in advance. So always have two keys - you lose one, get the replacement right away, or you'll need to tow your car to the dealer at your expense. Then it takes 2-3 days to have the key cut and sent to the dealer and programmed.