Hey, I'm Kyle from Vancouver Canada, new to the forum and new to VW.
Test drove a 2010 GTI on the weekend and fell in love. Currently drive a 2000 Subaru Impreza 2.5RS and was considering / had tested out a handfull of other potential purchases (WRX, used WRX STI, used A3 / A4, MS3, Used BMW 3-series etc). The GTI simply put a bigger smile on my face then the rest. I'm frankly a little surprised at myself that I'm leaving the Subaru family as I was a huge proponent of it's fantastic AWD system and the fact that my RS can still handle just as good / if not better than some of the new cars they're putting out these days - minus the GTI of course). What I'm losing in traction is insignificant to the fun-to-drive factor and the quality of the interior.
I was also surprised at the difference between the A3 and the GTI in terms of feel and driving dynamics...I had presumed these would be essentially the same car just with a different skin. I was wrong, the GTI seems so much more satisfying to drive.
That said, my mind is made up and I'll be swinging by the dealership this week to order my 2011 GTI 5-door in Black w/ the Tech and Luxury Pkgs. I will opt out of the 18" wheel option as I plan to use the 17s for my snow tires, then purchase a set of VMR v710s (or something similar) wrapped in summer rubber.
Cheers guys (and girls)